Graduate Guide

Levels of Evidence in Nursing Research: Hierarchies and How to Use Them

The two hierarchies nursing programs use most, how GRADE differs, and how to apply evidence levels in a literature review or evidence-based project.

Updated October 2026 · 7 min read

Levels of evidence in nursing research rank study designs by how well they protect against bias, so you can judge how much weight a finding deserves. Higher levels give more confidence that a result reflects a real effect.

Nursing programs do not all use the same hierarchy. This guide explains the two most common models, how GRADE takes a different approach, and how to use evidence levels well in a literature review, evidence table or DNP project.

Evidence Levels at a Glance

  • A level describes a study's design, not its quality. Appraisal judges quality separately.
  • Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt's hierarchy uses seven levels, with systematic reviews of randomized trials at Level I.
  • The Johns Hopkins model uses five levels plus a quality grade of A, B or C.
  • GRADE rates the certainty of a body of evidence for each outcome as high, moderate, low or very low.
  • Use the model your program names, and apply it consistently.

Why Evidence Hierarchies Exist

Different designs are vulnerable to bias in different ways. Randomization in a controlled trial spreads known and unknown confounders evenly between groups, which an observational study cannot do by design. A cohort study can show that two things occur together, but something else might explain the link.

Hierarchies therefore place syntheses of strong designs at the top, experimental designs next, observational designs in the middle, and opinion at the base. The ordering describes what each design can achieve on average. A poorly run trial can be less trustworthy than a careful cohort study, which is why levelling is always paired with appraisal.

The Seven-Level Hierarchy

Many nursing programs teach the seven-level hierarchy associated with Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt. It works well for questions about the effect of an intervention.

LevelEvidence type
ISystematic review or meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials; guidelines based on such reviews
IIAt least one well-designed randomized controlled trial
IIIControlled trials without randomization (quasi-experimental)
IVCase-control and cohort studies
VSystematic reviews of descriptive and qualitative studies
VIA single descriptive or qualitative study
VIIOpinion of authorities or reports of expert committees

The Johns Hopkins Model

The Johns Hopkins evidence-based practice model, widely used in hospitals and DNP programs, groups evidence into five levels and adds a separate quality rating. Check which edition of its appraisal tools your program uses, since wording has been updated over time.

LevelEvidence type
IExperimental studies, including randomized controlled trials, and systematic reviews of them
IIQuasi-experimental studies, and systematic reviews of these or of mixed experimental and quasi-experimental studies
IIINon-experimental and qualitative studies, and systematic reviews that include them
IVOpinion of respected authorities or expert panels based on scientific evidence, such as clinical practice guidelines and consensus statements
VExperiential and non-research evidence, such as integrative and literature reviews, quality improvement reports, case reports and expert opinion

Each source also receives a quality grade: A (high), B (good) or C (low or major flaws). A rating such as "Level II, quality B" therefore tells the reader both the design and how well it was carried out.

Note the key difference from the seven-level model: Johns Hopkins places qualitative studies at Level III alongside other non-experimental designs, and treats guidelines as Level IV, while the seven-level model can place guidelines based on systematic reviews at Level I.

GRADE: Certainty Rather than Rank

GRADE is used in systematic reviews and guideline development. Instead of ranking single studies, it rates the certainty of a whole body of evidence for one outcome.

  • Evidence from randomized trials starts as high certainty; observational evidence starts as low.
  • Certainty can be rated down for risk of bias, inconsistency, indirectness, imprecision and publication bias.
  • Observational evidence can be rated up for a large effect, a dose-response gradient, or when plausible confounding would reduce the observed effect.
  • The final rating is high, moderate, low or very low.

You will meet GRADE ratings in Cochrane reviews and guidelines. If you cite them, say so, and avoid mixing GRADE terms with your program's levels without explanation.

The 6S Pyramid and Pre-Appraised Evidence

Another model you may see is the 6S pyramid, developed from Haynes's earlier 4S and 5S versions. It is not a ranking of designs but a guide to where busy clinicians should look first, ordered by how much appraisal and synthesis has already been done.

  • Systems: computerized decision support linked to the patient record.
  • Summaries: evidence-based guidelines and point-of-care texts.
  • Synopses of syntheses: critical summaries of systematic reviews.
  • Syntheses: systematic reviews.
  • Synopses of studies: critical summaries of single studies.
  • Studies: individual original research.

The 6S model is useful for planning a search, because it pushes you to check for existing syntheses before screening hundreds of single studies. For rating sources in an evidence table, use a design hierarchy instead.

Matching Level to Question Type

Hierarchies are built mainly for intervention questions. Other questions call for different designs, and the "best" evidence changes accordingly.

Question typeStrongest usual design
Does an intervention work?Systematic review of randomized trials
What causes or predicts an outcome?Cohort studies, or reviews of them
How accurate is a test?Cross-sectional diagnostic accuracy studies
What is the experience of patients?Qualitative studies and qualitative evidence syntheses
How common is a condition?Well-sampled cross-sectional surveys

A qualitative study sits low on an intervention hierarchy, but for a meaning question it may be exactly the right evidence. Say which question type you are answering before you rank your sources.

A Worked Evidence Table Entry

Source. A multi-site cluster randomized trial of hourly rounding on fall rates in 18 medical units.

Seven-level model. Level II.

Johns Hopkins. Level I, quality B: randomization by unit and good follow-up, but no blinding of outcome assessors and fall reporting relied on incident reports.

Relevance. High. Adult medical units similar to the project setting.

Use in review. Anchors the theme on rounding interventions, weighed against two smaller quasi-experimental studies that found larger effects.

The same trial earns a different number in each model, which is why your evidence table must name the model it uses. The study described is illustrative.

Using Levels in Your Writing

  1. Organize the review by theme, then discuss evidence level within each theme.
  2. Let the highest-level, best-quality evidence anchor each theme.
  3. When high-level evidence is missing, say so plainly; that is a finding, not a failure.
  4. When designs agree, note that convergence strengthens confidence.
  5. When they disagree, weigh design and quality, and look for context such as population differences.
  6. State your own project's level in the discussion and what it means for interpretation.

Most capstone and DNP projects use pre-post, quality improvement or descriptive designs. These sit in the middle or lower levels, which committees expect. Naming the level and its implications shows methodological maturity.

Level, Quality and Relevance Are Different

Three separate questions apply to every source. What is its design, and so its level? How well was it carried out? How closely does it match your population, setting and intervention?

A Level I review of hospital trials may be less useful for a community clinic project than a strong local cohort study. A strong review weighs all three rather than mechanically choosing the highest level. For the appraisal step itself, see our guide on how to critically appraise nursing research.

How IvyDrafts Helps with Levels of Evidence

Send your PICOT question, your source list or PDFs and the hierarchy your program uses. A writer with graduate nursing experience returns a custom evidence table that levels and appraises each study, a synthesis section built on that table, or a review of your own table for consistency.

Every source is real and rated on what it actually reports. Free revisions within the scope of your original request are included and your identity is never shared with the writer.

Level and Appraise Your Evidence with Confidence

Send your sources and your program's hierarchy. Your writer returns a custom evidence table or synthesis that rates each study consistently.

Order an Evidence Table

Free revisions · Full refund if late · Written from scratch for your order

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the levels of evidence in nursing research?

They are rankings of study designs by their protection against bias. Common nursing models include Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt's seven levels and the Johns Hopkins five-level model with quality grades.

Is a randomized controlled trial always the best evidence?

For intervention questions, well-conducted trials and reviews of them are usually strongest. For questions about experience, prognosis or diagnosis, other designs may be more appropriate.

Where do qualitative studies fit?

In the seven-level model a single qualitative study is Level VI and a review of qualitative studies is Level V. In the Johns Hopkins model, qualitative studies sit at Level III.

What level is a clinical practice guideline?

It depends on the model. The seven-level model can place guidelines based on systematic reviews of trials at Level I, while Johns Hopkins classes guidelines as Level IV.

What is the difference between evidence level and quality?

Level reflects the design. Quality reflects how well a particular study was carried out, judged by appraisal.

What level is a DNP project?

Most DNP projects are quality improvement or pre-post designs, which sit in the middle or lower levels depending on the model. Committees expect this.

Do I have to use the Johns Hopkins model?

Use whatever model your program or organization specifies, cite it and apply it consistently.

Is GRADE a level of evidence system?

Not exactly. GRADE rates the certainty of a body of evidence for each outcome, rather than ranking individual studies.